2009-2010 All-stars
| Syracuse League 1
MVP: Josh Alley, Jordan-Elbridge Mateo Diz, Southern Cayuga Rachel Hare, Jordan-Elbridge Zac Leja, Port Byron Carly Signor, Southern Cayuga Matt Thomas, Union Springs |
Syracuse League 1
MVP: Ben Silverstein, Manlius-Pebble Hill Steve Anderson, Christian Brothers Colin Barber, Fayetteville-Manlius Caitlin Quigley, Fowler Drew Rotunno, Christian Brothers |
| Team sportsmanship
award: Cato-Meridian, Fowler |
2010 All-Tournament Playoff team |