2008-2009 All-stars
| Syracuse League 1
MVP: Josh Alley, Jordan-Elbridge Ryan Badman, Jordan-Elbridge Matt St. Martin, Port Byron Carly Signor, Southern Cayuga |
Syracuse League 2
MVP: Matthew Boban, Fayetteville-Manlius David Downing, Fowler Robbie Fredericks, Fayetteville-Manlius Meg Hourigan, Manlius-Pebble Hill Drew Rotunno, Christian Brothers |
| Team sportsmanship
awards Southern Cayuga, Fowler |
Syracuse 2009
Playoff All-tournament team MVP: |