2005-2006 Buffalo Area All-stars
| Buffalo League
1 MVP: Peter Costello, Lewiston-Porter Victoria Austin, Mt. St. Mary's Jon Gibbons, St. Joseph's Charlie Kruly, Williamsville South Allison Lyttle, Williamsville North Robert Niles, Williamsville East Patrick Walsh, Williamsville South |
Buffalo League 2 MVP: Mike Simich, Holland Dan Essrow, Kenmore East Emily Lodick, City Honors Ben Oseroff, City Honors Adam Pumm, Canisius Lee Spenger, East Aurora |
| Buffalo League
3 MVP: Brendan Chella, Orchard Park David Collins, West Seneca West Calle Fitzgerald, Lake Shore Andrew Geibel, Iroquois Joe Giglia, West Seneca East Jerry Richard, Orchard Park Stephen Trinder, Barker |
Buffalo League 4 MVP: Alex Sage, Lancaster Mark Coons, JFK Brigid Evans, Mt. Mercy Mandy Irish, JFK Sean Linehan, Park School Adam Marino, Cleveland Hill Forrest Smith, Grand Island |
| Team sportsmanship awards: Mt. St. Mary's, South Park, Iroquois, Grand Island |