2004-2005 All-stars
| Buffalo League
1 MVP: Katie Reedy, Nardin Matt Beato, Williamsville North Lexie Meyers, Williamsville South Rob Niles, Williamsville East Mike Oh, Williamsville East Connor Schratz, St. Joseph's Matt Simon, Bishop Timon |
Buffalo League 2 MVP: Emma Schmitt, Park School Dung Nguyen, City Honors Ben Oseroff, City Honors Nick Pangello, Canisius Mandi Thompson, Grand Island Brian Tyler, Lake Shore |
| Buffalo League
3 MVP: Brendan Chella, Orchard Park Matt Bean, West Seneca West Holly Bigelow, Barker Andrew Giebel, Iroquois Kippy Lexner, West Seneca East Dan Simich, Holland Lee Spengler, East Aurora |
Buffalo League 4 MVP: Patty McMahon, Mt. Mercy Andrew Andrzejak, Kenmore East Mandy Irish, JFK Mike Kratochvil, Kenmore East Brian Murray, Lancaster Sarah Passafiume, Cleveland Hill Alex Sage, Lancaster |
| Team sportsmanship awards:
Lewiston-Porter, Grand Island, Barker, Depew |